Fort Myers, FL Auto Insurance Rates

Fort Myers, FL residents can save $510 by comparing multiple quotes & reading reviews & research on Fort Myers car insurance rates, quotes, agents & coverage.

Compare Quotes from Top Providers and Save now!

$955 $1,280 $1,712

Latest Auto Insurance Reviews in Fort Myers, Florida

It's the least expensive I've found for the same, or better, liability coverage. I'm happy with it because I get a discount for paying six months at a time online.
Citizens Property Insurance
My premium is average as far as costs go. It's a necessity so no use complaining about it. My only complaint would be when to pay the premium.
It seems as though my premium is affordable, given the coverage that I have. I think the offerings are appropriate and suitable for my needs.
The premium with essurance is slightly lower than the premiums with other insurance companies for the same coverage. It is reasonable and there is not a large charge to break the payments up versus paying it for a year at a time.
I wish I could have a lower premium. Insurance costs are so high and I feel like I am not getting as much as I should for the money I pay. I think you pay a company enough every year that they should give you the best coverage. Especially when you have no claims to increase costs.
The premium is of really good value compared to other insurance agencies that I have looked into. On the flip side, there are some extras that are not included in that price.
Unfortunately one of the main drivers in my policy got in an accident causing the rate to go up, but it is still competitive with others based on driving history.
This is the only company I could find that offered coverage in the US and in the Virgin Islands
less expensive for the same coverage
Honestly I have not look at any competing companies, I have been very satisfied with the rates I have been offered and have not felt the need to look at other providers.
Compared to other insurance providers, I am able to have a lower deductible and higher coverage for a lower price.
I get full coverage for a very good price compared to my old insurance agency.
State Farm
Dependable service without penalty for using
available customer service reps used to be affordable
State Farm
My insurance is comparable to other insurance companies.
They have an app as well as a very friendly and efficient call center staff. The last time I used a claim I had a tow truck in 10 minutes and I wasn't in an especially well-populated area.
I honestly can say that there is not much I would change. I have never had an issue with their customer service and have always been great.
There may not be any physical locations for my company, but when you call them, they do everything they possibly can to fix whatever problem you are calling with.
Citizens Property Insurance
Being able to communicate through email is great. Having the ability to text chat and face time is paramount. Being we live in the country, it takes a while to get anywhere.
I like that it is all auto-pay so I don't have to really think about it. If I need any information, I will just go to the Geico website and see all the information there.
I"m apprehensive about calling in to speak with an agent because I feel like I may admonish for my history versus advised for ways to improve my experience.
They offered coverage worldwide with affordable premiums and excellent coverage options that I was able to custom fit to my needs. I would recommend them to anyone.
Prices, coverage, accessibility.
Well, I don't need comp in order to get roadside assistance. I an PARANOID car no go in the middle of nowhere. My only problem is the deadline.One time left stupid lights on the car and it was in a parking lot so no problem there. 1-hour service.
I mostly like the customer service, when we have called in the past they have bent over backward to help us or save us money.
I love that USAA takes care of my banking and my insurance at the same time. It is very convenient for me to only have one website/company to deal with so many things at one time.
I have all the access I can with Geico 24/7. It is great to be able to get in touch with Geico whenever I need to. The policy has been great and the price I pay is definitely worth it.
Citizens Property Insurance
Always willing to help. Never catch any flack from them about why I'm filing a claim. Agents are helpful and courteous and go above and beyond their duty every time I deal with them.
Motorist Insurance
The only thing I like about the company is that it's the cheapest insurance available to me. I plan on looking elsewhere soon though.
Liberty Mutual
I like them because they are not intrusive, I make my payments and they leave me alone. I think their cost is reasonable. I don't have any problems with them.
I like the prices for my coverage--Geico is very competitive and I feel like they work to get you the best possible rate. They make the claims process quick and easy.
the best thing for me about it is that the premium is the lowest I could find and I can combine it with my rental insurance to make it even cheaper
It is easy to get in contact with the company, people are friendly and helpful. Everything has gone smoothly and I am saving money. No complaints thus far.
I personally have no dislikes. I believe you have to be affiliated with the military to use them by blood or marriage so they are not available to everyone. But I would recommend them to anyone who qualifies.
I don't dislike anything about the company. I will never go through another company
I wish the premium were lower. Other than that, I like everything about them.
I wish I had a lower price on insurance since I barely drive around at all and there is no freaking traffic out here except deer and cattle.
Once again, I don't have anything bad to say, I guess I would always like cheaper rates in general.
What most people don't like about USAA is that there aren't any physical locations that we could walk into and deal with stuff.
Citizens Property Insurance
Costs are always going up. At least once a year I have an added cost added to my bill and have to call and have them correct it. It gets frustrating at times.
I would like it if there was a way to have the best coverage with a more affordable option. I would also like to feel like I can call in to express my concerns openly.
Write Your Review | Fort Myers, Florida Auto Insurance Analysis
Geico, Fort Myers, FL
$98/1 month
Car Insurance Policy Holder
  • Married 42 Years old Male licensed 9 years ago with Own Kia Rio LX used for Business with estimated annual mileage of 20,001+.
  • less than high school education & Full Time Job.
  • No accidents , No traffic tickets , No DUIs , No Licence suspensions .
Car Insurance Policy & Coverage Details:
  • 1 car insured & >3 people are part of this policy
  • Home and Auto insurance are from difference companies
  • $10K (Per Person Bodily Injury) / $20K (Per Accident Bodily Injury)
  • 10 K Property Damage
  • 25 K Personal Injury Protection
  • 10 K Uninsured Motorists Bodily Injury
  • 20 K Uninsured Motorists Property Damage

Fort Myers Car Insurance Rate Comparisons

Fort Myers, FL's average car insurance of $1280 differs from Three Oaks, FL (+$50), Tice, FL (+$600), Page Park, FL (+$620) and Florida (+$84)

Fort Myers Three Oaks, FL Tice, FL Page Park, FL Florida
Median Insurance Rates $1280 +$50 +$600 +$620 +$84

Fort Myers Car Insurance Savings By Neighborhood & Street Area

Fort Myers Driver Street Residence & Car Locations Car Details in Fort Myers Fort Myers Driver Demographics Fort Myers Auto Insurance Estimates Recent Fort Myers Insurance Savings
Tice Courts Mobile Home Park
Lavonne Ave2001 Cadillac Seville SLS79 year male senior$2,143$656
Melody Ct2003 Buick Rendezvous CXL23 year man$1,872$634
L St S2006 Ford Fusion V6 SEL16 year female teenager$2,920$604
Mastique Beach Blvd2006 Chrysler 300 C52 year woman$1,065$884
Indian Creek Park Mobile Home Park
A St N2010 Nissan Rogue S40 year married man$2,017$609
I St N2012 Hyundai Sonata GLS64 year female senior$1,818$670
Forest Island Park
Maida Ln2007 Lexus GS 35019 year male teenager$3,701$665
Sandel Wood Cir W2009 Acura TSX Base32 year married woman$1,091$393
Siesta Park Mobile Home Park
Atlanta Ave2010 Mazda 3 S67 year senior$1,792$904
Lexington Ave2013 Honda Civic LX16 year teenager$3,059$849

Fort Myers Post DUI Car Insurance Rates

Fort Myers Punta Rassa Gateway San Carlos Park Florida
Median Post DUI Insurance Rate $2380 +$1098 +$968 +$707 +$157
Male Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $6403 +$2952 +$2603 +$1901 +$421
Female Teenager Post DUI Insurance Rate $5713 +$2634 +$2322 +$1697 +$374

The Post DUI insurance in Fort Myers, FL's is $2380 compared to Punta Rassa (+$1098), Gateway (+$968), San Carlos Park (+$707) and Florida (+$157)

In Fort Myers, a male teenager with Post DUI pays $690 more than a female teenager Post DUI. For Example, a Male Teenager Post DUI with a 2006 Ford Fusion V6 SEL in Fort Myers, FL would pay $6087 on auto insurance while a female teenager POST DUI would pay $5431.

Fort Myers Car Insurance by Segment

Fort Myers Teenagers Car Insurance Rates Comparison

7425 Fort Myers Teenagers (5% of total population), 50% Male & 50% Female.

Fort Myers Estero Island Three Oaks Lochmoor Waterway Estates Florida
All Teenagers $3225 +$1311 +$126 +$504 +$212
Male Teenager $3443 +$1399 +$134 +$538 +$226
Female Teenager $3072 +$1248 +$120 +$480 +$201

Fort Myers teenagers pay $3225 in insurance in contrast with Estero Island (+$1311), Three Oaks (+$126), Lochmoor Waterway Estates (+$504) and Florida (+$212). The difference between Male & Female teenagers in Fort Myers is $371


  • 2010 Toyota Prius V Male Teenager Insurance Rate $3,311
  • 2004 Chevrolet Silverado 2500HD Work Truck Female Teenager Insurance Rate $2,964

Fort Myers Men & Women Car Insurance

147329 Fort Myers Adults (100% of total population), 49% Men & 51% Women.

Fort Myers Harlem Heights Punta Rassa Page Park Florida
All Women $1177 +$488 +$543 +$571 +$77
Married Women $1075 +$445 +$495 +$521 +$70
All Men $2112 +$874 +$973 +$1023 +$138
Married Men $2048 +$848 +$944 +$992 +$134

The typical insurance rate of $2112 that Fort Myers Men pay varies from Harlem Heights (+$874), Punta Rassa (+$973), Page Park (+$1023) and Florida (+$138). In Fort Myers, married men pay $973 more than married women.


  • 2012 GMC Sierra 1500 SLE Married Men Insurance Rate $1,848
  • 2014 Kia Sorento LX Married Women Insurance Rate $1,960

Fort Myers Senior Car Insurance

48741 Fort Myers Seniors (33% of total population), 45% Senior Men & 55% Senior Women.

Fort Myers Gateway Cypress Lake Estero Island Florida
All Seniors $1894 +$770 +$651 +$770 +$124
Senior Men $1945 +$791 +$669 +$791 +$128
Senior Women $1843 +$749 +$633 +$749 +$121

Fort Myers seniors pay $1894 in insurance compared to Gateway (+$770), Cypress Lake (+$651), Estero Island (+$770) and Florida (+$124). In Fort Myers, senior men pay $102 more than senior women.

Fort Myers Car Insurance Discounts for Multiple Vehicles

Fort Myers Population with 1 Vehicle 31642 (52% of Fort Myers population), 2 Vehicles 18855 (31% of the Fort Myers population) and 3 vehicles 3766 (6% of the population)

Fort Myers Estero Island Harlem Heights Fort Myers Beach Florida
2 Vehicles $2432 +$988 +$1007 -$53 +$160
3 Vehicles $3712 +$1508 +$1537 -$81 +$244
4 Vehicles $4992 +$2028 +$2067 -$109 +$328

Car Insurance Agents in Fort Myers, FL

Rank Agent Name Agent Contact
1 AAA Insurance 2516 Colonial Blvd, Fort Myers, FL 33907
2 Affordable Secure Insurance 16289 S Tamiami Trl, Fort Myers, FL 33908
3 Alan Williams & Associates 13720 Six Mile Cypress Pkwy Ste 2, Fort Myers, FL 33912
4 Alliance Insurance Agency 6338 Presidential Ct Ste 102, Fort Myers, FL 33919
5 Ann Clark 16440 S Tamiami Trl Ste 9, Fort Myers, FL 33908
6 A P Hill 1901 Brantley Rd Unit 11, Fort Myers, FL 33907
7 Art Roberts 13102 Palm Beach Blvd Ste B, Fort Myers, FL 33905
8 At Your Service Insurance 9101 College Pkwy Ste 203, Fort Myers, FL 33919
9 Avalon Insurance Group 7370 College Pkwy Ste 312, Fort Myers, FL 33907
10 BABB, Inc. 2451 1st St, Fort Myers, FL 33901